The Maine Human Rights Commission (MHRC) cleared University of Southern Maine Sociology and Education Professor Dr. Christy Hammer of any wrongdoing after she faced backlash for saying that there are only two sexes.
Dr. Hammer made headlines in September 2022 after she informed a graduate-level education class that there are only two sexes, along with a vanishingly small number of “intersex” people, born with defects in their sexual development.
“Biologists are canceled if they don’t admit that there’s a sex spectrum, there’s some gradations between male and female. And as one biologist said, there are people that are born with nine fingers and people that are born with 11, but we don’t say the number of fingers is a spectrum,” said Hammer speaking with the Maine Wire.
An MHRC investigator report published in August cleared both the University of Southern Maine and Hammer of any violation of Maine’s anti-discrimination laws after a non-binary identifying student, Elizabeth Leibiger, issued a formal complaint.
“There are No Reasonable Grounds to believe that University of Southern Maine discriminated against Elizabeth Leibiger on the basis of gender identity; There are No Reasonable Grounds to believe that Christy Hammer interfered with Elizabeth
Leibiger’s right to be free of discrimination based on gender identity; and the complaint should be dismissed,” said MHRC investigator Colin Hurd.
Although the investigator made his report in August, Hammer only recently opened up about her exoneration to the media.
Leibiger claimed that Hammer’s affirmation of binary biological sex, along with incidents in which Hammer says she accidentally “misgendered” Leibiger by referring to him as she, constituted a hostile and discriminatory educational environment.
Hammer told the Maine Wire that the controversy began during the second day of her education class when Leibiger rushed in late, demanding that Hammer answer how many sexes she believes there are after hearing that Hammer had only acknowledged two sexes in a previous class.
“Two sexes with variation,” Hammer recalled saying.
“She said, You’re not fit to teach this class. She was picking up her books as she was saying that, pointing her finger at me, she turned around and walked out, and three other students immediately left with her,” Hammer said.
Hammer disputed reports claiming that the entire class stormed out, specifically citing a report from the Bangor Daily News that said all but one student walked out.
Hammer said only three other students stormed out with Leibiger, and that 15 out of the 22 students remained in the class.
The MHRC report seemed to corroborate Hammer’s statements, although it claimed that four to five students stormed off with Leibiger, and that 13, not 15, students decided to remain in her class.
Other parts of the report say that “several” students left, but it never suggests that the majority of the class left.
The Maine Wire reached out to the Bangor newspaper, asking if they intend to issue a correction to their story covering the incident.
They told The Maine Wire that they will look into the correction request.
The rest of the students transferred into an alternate class established by the school to cover the same material for students uncomfortable with Hammer’s description of human biology.
The MHRC report claimed that the school asked Hammer not to contact her students, but that she nevertheless reached out via email to them to address the situation.
The school’s Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) administrator, Sarah Holmes, set up a “restorative justice circle” for aggrieved students to speak with Hammer.
She initially believed that the restorative justice circle would provide an opportunity for her to remedy the division in her class.
Instead, she said, the three-hour event was spent with students trying to force her to retract her statement that there are only two sexes, and berating her for refusing to announce her preferred pronouns.
The school decided not to fire Hammer, as Leibiger reportedly wanted, but did allegedly try to force her to declare her pronouns and change the way she discusses sexual distinctions in class.
Hammer said that she is currently searching for a lawyer specializing in freedom of speech issues so she can sue the University of Southern Maine for allegedly violating her First Amendment rights.
If such a case were to be brought, it would not be the first time the University of Southern Maine has been sued for allegedly violating an academic’s free speech rights.
In 2023, Dr. Patricia Griffin filed a civil case against the University claiming she was fired for expressing her criticisms of COVID-19 policies.
[RELATED: UMaine Professor Fired For Criticizing Mask Mandates Fighting for Her Free Speech Rights…]
The report showed that the school opened Title IX proceedings against Hammer and found that she created a “hostile learning environment” by misgendering Leibiger.
Hammer appealed that ruling in April 2023.
Hammer told the Maine Wire that the school has relegated her to teaching lower-level undergraduate classes, whereas before the controversy, she taught graduate-level courses.
She said that further penalties are forthcoming despite the vindicating MHRC report, but the school has not yet revealed to her what they will be.
During her interview with the Maine Wire, Hammer pointed out that she was an unlikely target for this sort of controversy, citing an unspecified article describing the incident as “the woke attacking the woke.”
She described herself as a “hard-left sociologist” and told the Maine Wire that she has previously served on the board of an LGBT youth advocacy group and worked in DEI.
Updated to include a response from the Bangor Daily News.
Thanks for asking BND to cover this update! Yes, 15 of 22 students chose my section of the class to stay in but it ended up being 13 of 22 as two students dropped out, one quoting the Canceling of the American Mind and apologizing to me, deciding he didn’t want to be a teacher seeing how other students acted.
Also, Seamus misunderstood: I only contacted the students once by email at 6am expressing my disappointment with the BDN article and noting I would meet with the dean later than morning, and did not contact the students again afterwards (after the dean asked me not to.). There was a literal one word typo that I corrected, and The Student freaked out and said that I was contacting her inappropriately. Besides an initial apology before the BDN story broke, I never contacted this student.
This bullying to stifle free speech and force absurdity upon us has got to stop. Hopefully, now that the rush of woke “wisdom” has passed, sanity will return.
The United States can’t survive with the type of press we’re now saddled with. The BDN is horrible and its remaining readership is even worse.
“She described herself as a “hard-left sociologist” and told the Maine Wire that she has previously served on the board of an LGBT youth advocacy group and worked in DEI.”
Say no more.
Let me guess… someone checked.. and there were only two.
Walke up Maine. See what your Collage is thinking!
I’m quite sure a luxurious safe space for this student , paid in full by tax dollars supporting the university, would ameliorate the bruised feelings and resolve the situation – but for the full on support of the school’s administrators. It’s akin to the Twilight Zone; but even Rod Serling’s creatively twisted mind could not make up this culturally denigrating scenario. We need a sea change of mindset to save our society.
University of Southern Maine personnel who are involved in this issue should be required to complete a medical school embryology course where they will learn the stages of embryological development resulting in two normal sexes and the many developmental anomalies, including anatomical sex anomalies, which may occur at various stages. Otherwise, they are not qualified to be involved in this issue.
Thanks for your comments! Pathetic that BDN refuses so far to correct the misinformed story. Even a USM prof told me what happened was what many outside academia are afraid happens, and it’s “why we got Trump” (that was said in ’22 about the ’16 election!). The student submitted as evidence I should be fired a letter from their therapist that mental health issues had worsened since Professor Hammer answered “two sex” and unintentionally said “she” instead of “they”.
STOP the drama and the WOKE ideology! I earned a degree in Sociology from USM during the 1990’s. When in hell did the Sociology Department go off the rails and allow this type of abhorrent behavior in the classroom? This never would have happened when I was in college! First of all we had much more respect for our teachers and professors. We didn’t have this “entitlement mentality” that students have today. As long as the administration allows this, it will continue. I’d look for a different college to attend!
A “ Restorative Justice Circle “ ….LOL LOL
WHERE do these loonies come up with these names ?
My only question is : “ Is your little circle held in the dark or in the daylight ? “
What a bunch of losers !
Ms . / Mr, ( whatever ) Leibiger needs a swift kick in the ass .
Let her move to California and she can go to school there .
Ms. Elizabeth Leibiger may have difficulty keeping any job she may get in the future. It appears to me she has some massive boundary issues, and “TED: The Empowerment Dynamic” offers an effective and accessible remedy for her incredibly childish and bullying behavior.
https://www.alibris.com/booksearch?mtype=B&keyword=9780996871808&hs.x=0&hs.y=0
So this is a graduate level education student. The prospect that this allegedly learned individual could be teaching my grandchildren, or any young students in the future, is most disturbing.